When the trailer for ‘Boy, with Caution’ first dropped, the comment section was flooded with viewers fuming over the controversial teacher-student romance trope. However, as it turns out, there’s a little more to the story.
Although set in a high school, ‘Boy, with Caution’ follows 21-year-old Lee Hyeon Jae (Ha Jung Hoon), who returns to school after a two-year absence due to health issues. He’s the son of the school chairman, but instead of being the stereotypical rich, entitled bully, Hyeon Jae is a lonely, isolated young man suffering under his father’s abusive behaviour. So when a new temporary teacher, Jang Gi Woo (Ryu Se Il), shows him some much-needed kindness, Hyeon Jae begins to mistake his concern for romantic affection.
Directed by Lee Son Eum (Gray Shelter), ‘Boy, with Caution’ spans eight episodes following two lonely souls weighed down by expectations they cannot seem to escape. Jang Gi Woo is in the middle of a divorce, something he has yet to confess to his overbearing single mother. His teaching career is already hanging by a thread thanks to past rumours of inappropriate conduct, and with neither friends nor family to turn to, Gi Woo finds himself increasingly isolated. Perhaps it is this familiarity with loneliness that makes him sensitive to the struggles of his students. So when Hyeon Jae repeatedly shows up at school sporting suspicious bruises, Gi Woo cannot help but take an interest in the troubled young man.
This really isn’t the salacious teacher-student BL romance some were pegging it to be. Instead, Boy, with Caution is a bleak, gloomy drama, with Ryu Se Il portraying Gi Woo with the resignation of a man struggling to piece his life back together while trying to ward off his student’s misplaced attraction towards him. Hyeon Jae wastes little time acting on his crush and is left confused and conflicted when the teacher doesn’t respond to his overtures. An anonymous online chat, where the two unwittingly connect, further complicates their bond, especially when the student figures out who he’s talking to, while Gi Woo remains completely in the dark.
The show also delves into themes of bullying, illicit drug dealing, and the efforts of a small group of students to constantly target Gi Woo and pin their misdemeanours on him. Lee Jung Chan plays Kim Jeong Ha, a desperate, impoverished athlete who takes up whatever odd jobs he can find to pay his grandmother’s bills. One such gig requires him to brutally beat up Hyeon Jae, building some suspense over whether he will really stoop to such lengths for money.
A rather unnecessary secondary romance between Jeong Ha and his studious friend Park Seong Won (Jung Si Wan) doesn’t make much sense in the context of Boy, With Caution’s primary premise. Seong Won serves as Jeong Ha’s moral compass, trying to dissuade him from turning into a goon, which is a nice touch, but the two could’ve simply remained friends. Also, I’m beginning to get a little tired of the ‘sick grandmother’ trope. ‘Dive into My Bad Rival‘, ‘Edge of Horizon‘, and ‘Connecting With You‘ are three other shows that used the same subplot at some point in their stories, and all came out in the same year!
There’s significant tension between the leads throughout the series, particularly over whether Gi Woo will eventually give in to Hyeon Jae’s relentless romantic advances. Ha Jung Hoon brings a complex character to life with conviction: despite his tough exterior and intimidating, almost bully-like appearance, Hyeon Jae is surprisingly sensitive, kind, and thoughtful, which makes the constant abuse and rejection he faces quite heartbreaking. It’s the same reason why Gi Woo cannot bring himself to abandon the troubled young man, even as he strictly tries to draw a line between them.
‘Boy, with Caution’ maintains a consistently bleak, gloomy atmosphere, with the cold winter mirroring the emotional turmoil of its characters. There’s heartbreak in the climactic episode, but the story ultimately wraps up on a cold, practical note, one that makes the most sense given the complicated relationship at its centre. And as the series draws to a close, there’s a sense that the long, difficult winter might finally be coming to an end. Summer, and with it a little warmth and happiness, is just around the corner, if only the men can find their way towards it.
Watch Boy, with Caution on GagaOlala.
Find the writer on Twitter | Instagram
Looking for more BLs to watch? Check out quick reviews of three dramas below.
