Follow us on Twitter | Instagram
So, I get it, Variety released a list of ‘100 Greatest Movie Stars’ and it’s not about their acting skills, but more about their star power, AKA the crowds and cheers they draw when they walk into a street. But in a list where Marylin Monroe places number one and Shah Rukh Khan is the only Indian actor, it feels more like a random rage-bait article than anything else.
Because… excuse us, what about the mass hysteria Bollywood star Rajesh Khanna used to cause at the peak of his career? Fans wrote him letters in blood and married his photographs in the 1960s and 70s. No Amitabh Bachchan. No Rajinikanth, whose films still get the kind of whistles and hoots no Hollywood star does.
It doesn’t have a single Chinese mainland actor. Seriously? Untamed star Xiao Zhan gets routinely mobbed at airports even now and has 34 million followers just on Weibo! This list doesn’t even have Jackie Chan! Conduct a poll in India or any Asian country that’s not China, and I’d bet that far more people would recognize Jackie Chan than a good majority of the actors on this 100 greatest movie stars of all time list. And that alone should tell you something about how narrowly the publication defines global stardom.
Bruce Lee is there in the list, but he was Chinese-American. Why did this list even bother including Shah Rukh Khan, if it was going to be mostly about Hollywood stars.
Where are the great Egyptian stars, such as Omar Sharif and Faten Hamama? Where are South Korea’s major screen icons? What about Latin American cinema?
“To choose the 100 Greatest Movie Stars, we had to use our heads, our hearts, our guts, our fantasy lives. We were looking for the stars who magnetize us, the ones who awe and overpower us and make us swoon,” explain the opening lines of the feature. Then it’s criminal to not have Rajesh Khanna on the list! Women would faint at the sight of his car!
To be fair, they do mention Japanese cinema legend Toshiro Mifune, alongside European greats like Sophia Loren and Marcello Mastroianni. But these few names are swimming in a sea of Hollywood royalty.
Variety set out to rank the 100 greatest movie stars of all time, only to discover that apparently most of them lived and worked somewhere between Hollywood and London. Their comment section is filled with remarks of readers wondering where their own favorite star is.
Of course, compiling a list like this is no easy task, and there’s bound to be disagreement over who deserves a spot. But perhaps conducting a massive global audience poll, or getting at least 100 professional film critics from around the world to weigh in, would’ve been a better way to go about it. After all, if you’re going to crown the greatest movie stars of all time, shouldn’t the rest of the world get a say too?
Their list is less a definitive ranking of the greatest movie stars of all time than a revealing portrait of Hollywood’s cultural memory. Its greatest weakness isn’t whom it celebrates, but how much of world cinema it seems to have forgotten.
Read Next: Run with the Wind Review: Five-Star Treat! (Audio Version Below)
